Okay friends!! I think I have tried every single recipe out there to make my own play doh and I never found one that I love!! I really wanted to make my own colors- I just loved all those soft pastels and nude colors you see on Pinterest. So I kept on thinking and thinking and thought what if I bought plain white play doh in a giant tub and added my own dye!!!! Let me tell you what happened next....I finally got my Pinterest play doh with those gorgeous soft pastel colors!! And it was super simple!
Buy already made white non toxic play doh on Amazon
add as many drops of dye as you want ( I wanted a really soft color so I added less than a drop and I used gel food coloring)
knead until color is mixed
at this point you can add glitter if you want and knead again
I hope you find this useful and stress free. I also like this idea better than the diy flour play doh because for some reason my dog loves to eat the flour playdoh...Im guessing he thinks it bread ...hahaha